Hebrews 5:12-14 (KJV) "For when for the time ye ought to be teachers, ye have need that one teach you again which be the first principles of the oracles of God; and are become such as have need of milk, and not of strong meat. For every one that useth milk is unskilful in the word of righteousness: for he is a babe. But strong meat belongeth to them that are of full age, even those who by reason of use have their senses exercised to discern both good and evil."
Proverbs 27:17 (KJV) "Iron sharpeneth iron; so a man sharpeneth the countenance of his friend."
In January, the production company Base Hologram announced its forthcoming Roy Orbison hologram tour, “In Dreams,” with the U.S. leg of the tour set to kick off on Oct. 1 in Oakland. For the unitiated: A computer-generated hologram of Orbison will be performing alongside an orchestra and band.
Shortly after the announcement, a handful of critics reacted with such horror that you would have thought the very future of music and morality were under siege.
Some saw it as an inauthentic, soulless attempt to mimic his live shows. Others accused the organizers of exploiting a dead artist without his consent and even erasing the line between life and death.
So you might assume that I would echo these critics and view the Roy Orbison hologram tour with suspicion.
However I had a chance to see the Orbison hologram concert in London on April 18. If anything, it was a fitting tribute to Orbison’s legacy and a logical step in the evolution of live performances.
A different sort of star
When Roy Orbison attained international fame in the 1960s, rock ‘n’ roll hadn’t seen or heard anyone like him.
He’d gotten his start in west Texas in the mid-1950s with his band The Teen Kings. He then moved to Sun Records in Memphis, where he joined rockers such as Elvis Presley and Jerry Lee Lewis.
During this early period, much of Orbison’s music – and The Teen Kings’ energetic onstage performances – mimicked the era’s flashy, macho style.
By 1964, however, Orbison had become a different sort of performer. He started dressing in black and wearing sunglasses. During shows, he stood still and seldom spoke between songs, many of which were ballads.
In hits like “Running Scared” and “Crying,” he doesn’t boast about his sexual prowess; instead, he croons about male fear and emotional paralysis.
Roy Orbison performs ‘Running Scared’ during a 1965 show.
He was largely self-taught and eschewed the common “verse-chorus-bridge” structure of the era, penning complex compositions that often built towards melodramatic climaxes of pain, loss and anxiety. When recording, he augmented guitars and drums with violins and orchestral string instruments, and he sang in a four-octave range.
For this reason, some see Orbison as more like a classical musician than a rock star. During a 2007 speech honoring Orbison at the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, Elvis Costello compared Orbison’s song “Crawling Back” to classical composer Robert Schumann’s songs.
In this way, he also challenged conventional gender roles of the times. As Bono exclaimed in a video played during the hologram concert: “He sings like a girl!”
Musicians such as Chris Isaac, Bernie Taupin and Bruce Springsteen have also spoken of their deep admiration for Orbison. They described his stage presence – and body – in unusual terms: He was “godlike,” “frail” and “angelic,” “unique to the species” or “from another planet.”
As Bruce Springsteen remarked, he looked like someone you could put your hand through – much like a hologram.
But you would think, based on some of the responses to Orbison’s tour, that its organizers were committing sacrilege. Even a mostly positive review noted that the show “feels like a ghoulish cash-in, trading on gimmickry and shock value,” that there was “something very ethically unsettling about the whole endeavour.”
Yet for all the flak hologram concerts have received, music shows have long been anything but “live.”
Where’s the outrage over giant video projection screens, which eliminate the unmediated presence of the performer? Unless you’ve been able to score choice tickets, you’ll spend most arena shows staring at a Jumbotron.
Then there’s the music itself. Many shows today feature prerecorded instrumentals and verses. Some hip-hop artists perform with just their laptops, while remixes and sampling are common in recordings. Duets with deceased artists have become more common, too: Raul Malo “covered” Simon and Garfunkle’s “Bridge Over Troubled Water” with none other than Roy Orbison, who had been dead for over a decade.
In this sense, holograms don’t upend musical tradition. Instead, they’re just another evolutionary step.
In fact, computer-generated artists like Lil Miquela represent an even more extreme pole. Hologram concerts use digitally recreated images of artists who were once alive. But there’s no real person or body behind these digitally-created, fictional ones.
The man who was never there
There’s something particularly fitting about a hologram tour featuring Roy Orbison.
His public persona was so mysterious that his fans didn’t know much about the man behind the shades.
In the early 1960s he had no publicist and did few interviews. Music and entertainment magazines rarely covered him, and he seldom appeared on television. His greatest hits albums didn’t even have cover photos of him.
He seemed to be defined by an absence, which then materialized as a dark, quiet persona who always kept his eyes covered in public, inviting people to project their thoughts, fears and melancholy onto him.
At the London show, the concert emphasized, from the very beginning, the unreality of Orbison’s body: The hologram emerged from the floor of the stage – defying physics – and later disappeared into the floor before intermission.
The hologram tour also mimicked Orbison’s approach to his live shows. The specter of Orbison performed standing in one place and didn’t speak between songs; likewise, the audience sat quietly during the set, soaking in his words and music.
There were no screaming fans or adoring groupies. No one threw anything at the hologram knowing it could go through him, not to him
But Roy Orbison was an unusual rock star, and such antics were never common at his concerts. Perhaps this makes Orbison – the man who was never really there – an ideal avatar for this new form of music.
AWFSM is the #1 source for christian faith based independent alternative news, views, & videos;
challenging the way we read the news. Our christian themed bi-monthly publication presents up to date inspiration, information, & exhortation. You will not find AWFSM like any other mainstream headline news site, nor like any other global alternative news feed. We at AWFSM endeavor to jumpstart your spirit and your mind together to be ignited & inspired fresh today!
DISCLAIMER: Important Notice
AWFSM is an independent non profit endeavor. This site may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. AWFSM presents news worthy material available in an effort to inspire a faith based understanding of our environment, politics, human rights, economics, science, & social justice issues; etc.; AWFSM believes this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. All material is protected according to general copyrights for all authors & used under the Fair Use Statements. AWFSM does not endorse any third party links. Any added scriptural references are by AWFSM. Please see AWFSM Mission Statement. Thank You.